Friday, May 18, 2012

Book Review : “Red Tide” by Peg Brantley

Red Tide_sm

Red Tide

A great mystery – as much a whodunit as a what-done-it - , wrapped up in a page turning thriller. It’s rare when a debut book in a much scrutinized genre is written this well. The story and premise is original, the plot excellently executed, the dialog drives the piece along at a relentless pace (I finished the book at 2:36 a.m. and if I hadn’t been so satisfied, I would have been mad at myself since 5:00 a.m. was just around the corner and not to be avoided). The characters seem plucked from real life, and their traits, foibles and daily life are things that aren’t just topical but very much at the forefront of current events. And there are many characters, but the reader won’t have a hard time keeping them all straight, they are all individuals, memorable and necessary. Brantley is to be applauded for this if nothing else; she kept all those different balls in the air until the grand finale. Well done!

Brantley draws the Colorado scenery in such a masterful way that you’ll be tempted to stop and shop for skis and checking Expedia for hotels, but never fear, the book won’t allow you to put it down. Plot and story line; A+, character development a strong A, pace another A+, sense of place A+ and extra credit for both a plot device (the Red Tide of the title) and issues that are topical. You can’t get much better than that your first time out of the gate, but I’d bet money that Brantley manages to get even better.

The story opens when FBI Agent Nick Grant accepts a call from a serial killer he helped put away over a decade ago. Leopold Bonzer admitted killing fourteen people, but only gave up the location of one. He is holding the knowledge of the location of thirteen victims as a bargaining chip, but for what is the question. He seemingly is happy where he is at. Colorado’s Super Max prison, the Alcatraz of the Rockies. Bonzer is ready to trade now and Grant, who has been haunted for a decade by not being able to give closure to thirteen families, is ready to listen. Bonzer is suddenly wanting to relocate out of the cold cement and steel facility. But not today, he wants it all in writing before he’ll give it up. But when Grant heads back to make the deal, the prison is in lock down, even cell phones are being jammed, attack dogs are loose and Grant has a fear of dogs. Grant also has a prescription drug problem.

There has been an escape attempt, and during the confusion Bonzer has mysteriously died. Maybe from natural causes, but it seem too coincidental. Grant looks through Bonzer’s stark cell for some kind of clue. He discovers a photograph hidden behind the stainless steel mirror. But there is no description of where the photo was taken. It is just a meadow surrounded by mountains and forest. Grant feels certain that it is the burial ground but with no idea of the locale, the case seems to be forever at a dead end.

During this same time, in Aspen Falls, CO., Jamie Taylor has been called out, along with her dogs, to locate the body of a missing woman.  Jamie’s day job is as a loan officer at a bank where she makes enough to support herself and barely keep up with the upkeep on her families mountain home. She also is relied upon to help her sister, Jackie “Jax” Susman, who is the local medical Examiner, financially. Jax is married to a looser and abuser husband with a gambling, drinking and womanizing problem and Jackie makes excuses for him as he digs them deeper into debt.

What Jamie finds is the missing woman, but she also happens upon many more graves. The FBI is called in and the photo Grant is now in possession of, matches up with the presumed burial ground of serial killer, Bonzer. Problem is, there are decade old bodies, but there are also bodies of victims dead a year two at most. It’s no great stretch of the imagination to deduce that there is a new serial killer at work, and he is using Bonzer’s mountain meadow as a place to dispose of his victims.

Brantley brings in the supporting cast, Jamie’s sister, Jax, who despite her professional acclaim continues to allow herself to be used and abused by her husband Phil. Jamie's girlfriends, Ciara, a model, and Ellen who falls for a young junior FBI agent. Then there is Jamie and Jax father, who has not been around for ten years. Jamie’s vocation may be a bank loan officer, but her passion is her dogs,  superiorly trained tracking dogs and cadaver dogs. Jamie is driven to help find murder victims because her mother was one. Her father was with a mysterious private international security agency when his wife and Jamie and Jax mother was kidnapped and murdered in a gruesome way. Bryce Taylor has been on the murderers trail ever since, sometime crossing the boundaries of the law in his search.

The romantic tension between Grant and Jamie is instantaneous, but they also rub each other the wrong way when Grant mistakenly takes Jamie as a hobbyist with her dogs. But then Grant has a deep fear of dogs, instilled from a bad experience as a child and that may be part of his distancing himself from Jamie. Together, these characters must try and find the new serial killer, and along with the local sheriff they unravel one clue after another. Brantley knows her subject matter very well and the research she did into the intricacies of cadaver dogs as well as Red Tide algae of the title, add fascinating details without slowing the story down.

The chase and the conclusion will have the reader riveted to the pages. Brantley also explores themes of otherwise strong women that remain with and make excuses for abusive men. Additionally, she  delves into the psyche of serial killers in ways that are fresh to readers of the genre. There are very few weak spots in the story, which is promising in a debut author. This book will go a long way in introducing Brantley to readers as a force to be reckoned with in the thriller/mystery niche.

PegPeg Brantley is Colorado native and a prominent member of Rocky Mountain Fiction Writers, Sisters In Crime and the Crime Fiction Collective, who has just partnered with Herr and her husband live near Denver where they enjoy the animals that wander through their neck of the woods, including a bichon named McKenzie.


The Dirty Lowdown

Copyright © 2012 Robert Carraher All Rights Reserved

Article first published as Book Review : Red Tide by Peg Brantley on Blogcritics.


  1. Let me try again. I thought I'd left a comment earlier but maybe I dreamed it.

    Thank you, Robert. Slience from you wouldn't have raised a hair of suspicion from me if you hadn't liked my book. But I'm very pleased that you did.

    Thank you for the time and trouble you took to write this amazing review. I'm looking forward to a "private conversation" with you about the weak spots in the story. I want to continue to grow as a writer.

  2. thanks for sharing.